FSMIS (February 13,
2013): On
February 1, after a series of consultative meetings with Yap State leaderships,
traditional leaders, the private sector and NGO’s regarding the Chinese ETG
investment proposal, President Manny Mori shared with Governor Sebastian Anefal
and the Yap State Legislature a document on what transpired at those meetings
with recommendations.
ETG stands
for Exhibit and Travel Group, a Chinese business with overseas investments and
operations.
President
Mori indicated to both Governor Anefal and the Yap State Legislature that
moving forward with the scaled-back ETG investment would be in the best
interest of Yap State and the Federated States of Micronesia (FSM). However, he
stressed that the decision to allow ETG to proceed rests with Yap State.
The
President decided to take on the consultative meetings in mid-January in hope that
conclusive leadership decisions can be achieved soon enough. He said in his
meeting report, “because of the current impasse and the lack of a clear
understanding of the role that the national government has in terms of foreign
direct investments, I though it is incumbent on me, as President, to address
the issues directly with the concerned parties and see how I can bring their
divergent views together towards a more accommodating and acceptable
alternative”.
In the same
report, President Mori stated that the initial ETG investment interest in Yap
was to include the construction of 10,000 room hotel facilities, golf courses,
casinos, a convention center and other “entertainment support facilities”.
“I must say
that I also have concern about the initial scale of the project”, the President
highlighted before saying that the investment plan has been dramatically
reduced so that no golf course and casino will be included and that only 1,500
hotel rooms will be constructed. He went on to say that further demands for
scaling back and restrictions on the investment may not be financially viable
for ETG, risking cancellation of interest altogether by the Chinese investors.
In terms of
economic benefits, the President envisioned increase in tax revenue from
various ETG-related infrastructure constructions and creation of new services
and jobs. It is anticipated that tax revenues to Yap State resulting from the
ETG investments will be even greater if the proposed Value Added Tax scheme is
implemented.
President
Mori spoke of the lack of information and the unanswered worries by the general
public as complicating situations. He encouraged the leadership and ETG to
engage the people as far as providing details and transparent information to
cast away misunderstanding and create openness. He also spoke against providing
wrong information as doing so will only provoke ill feeling toward investment
and development in general.
Other issues
that were commented on by the President in his meeting report touched upon some
impacts and their possible remedies in areas having to do with land issues,
environmental protection and cultural way of life.
“This ETG
tourism investment proposal may be one of the answers to our desire to bring
about meaningful development to our islands. We may not see another opportunity
like this ETG proposal in our lifetime especially if there are no legitimate
reasons to reject the investment proposal at the scaled-back level”, President
Mori wrote at the end of his meeting report.
The
President’s ETG meetings report could be read entirely on the link below:
1) ETG stands for Exhibition & Travel Group, a Chinese "Mega-Resort" developer (not an investment company, they use predominantly OPM (Other People's Money, in the Yap case, the PRC owned China Import-Export Bank)).
ReplyDelete2) The "Dramatically reduced investment proposal" (its new "scaleback level) is so far (Feb 14 2013) completely unknown to all except a select few (maybe only Manny?). In the last publicized communication on the matter (ETG letter to Governor Anefal), the so called "scaleback" was simply breaking the original proposal into "phases" -- same number of facilities as originally proposed -- and also adding "development of the Outer Islands, where appropriate"...
3) Opinion: This is very far from "Meaningful" development. For one thing, if the travel market goes sour for whatever reason, Yap will be left with a collection of "White Elephants" (abandoned, ugly, unmaintainable "resort facilities")
Henry K.O. Norman
Independent Researcher